Peel & boil in salted water enough potatoes to make a large bowl full. Boil until just tender enough to chop in small pieces. Drain & chop potatoes.
Add:
I don't measure this very accurately, but usually mix and taste. I add enough of the pickle juice to make it thin enough to stir easily. If it is too sweet, add a little vinegar. I place in bowl, and shred American or Cheddar cheese on top & sprinkle with paprika. Keep cold.